Archive: Debate Club


Getting on the soap box for the music-related debates we should be having.

December 16th, 2011

They say that the world was built for Fine Tune Friday

lana_5511_north_584x0

Lana Del Rey, “Video Games” find it on Born To Die Remember the episode in Parks and Recreation where Leslie gives Ann a bunch of books to research and includes Jonathan Franzen’s Freedom only because “I’m dying to talk to someone about Patty”? That’s kind of how I feel about “Video Games”. It’s a song [...]

Keep on reading on »
July 15th, 2011

Fine Tune Friday finds some great metal, a sadly rare thing

liturgy

Liturgy, “Generation” find it on Aesthethica I hate almost all metal. I don’t hate it in that fingers-in-the-ears, you-call-this-music way. My problem with the majority of metal is that it’s the exact opposite of soul. Completely contrary to it’s reputation, it’s often some of the most uptight music made: painfully self-conscious and desperate for attention. [...]

Keep on reading on »
March 17th, 2011

Why Hatful Of Hollow is inferior to Louder Than Bombs in every way but one

hatful_vs_bombs

Like a ton of other people, I’m sure, my Smiths fandom has gotten a good stoking lately by the flurry of articles around the 25th anniversary of The Queen Is Dead. But instead of tackling that album, I’m starting a fight about something that’s always bugged me: Hatful Of Hollow‘s status as a classic, and [...]

Keep on reading on »
November 30th, 2010

Blur vs Oasis, Fifteen Years Later

blur+vs+oasis

Fifteen (!) years ago, there was a question being asked of English music fans that was so pervasive, it even made it into the UK national news: “Who do you like better, Blur or Oasis?” At least, I’m told that this was a question asked a lot. The only personal knowledge I have of it [...]

Keep on reading on »
September 9th, 2010

The real price of free music

2178340815_37388170cc

There’s any number of theories around about what will happen to how we buy and listen to music as digital becomes the standard. But optimists and cranks agree that the days of making tons of money with recorded music—let alone a living—are coming to a close. It’s not just that people expect music to be [...]

Keep on reading on »
January 21st, 2009

Singles vs. Albums vs. Both vs. Neither vs. All

A favorite debate of mine was rekindled in my brain (and now, here, and hopefully again in the comments) by this excellent post by singer and former Soul Coughing frontman Mike Doughty. His main target is the year-end lists of best albums (an argument that’s valid, but a little early, I think), but the blast [...]

Keep on reading on »
September 18th, 2008

I wanna make you wait

About a year ago, when In Rainbows came out and Limo and I first started sharing an office, we had a day or two’s worth of distraction from work talking about what their move to release the album only days after they’d announced it really meant for the world. It was a pretty exciting time, [...]

Keep on reading on »